Let's talk: editor@tmv.in
SC Dismisses Plea Seeking Restoration Of 250-Year-Old Shenbagavalli Weir

SC Dismisses Plea Seeking Restoration Of 250-Year-Old Shenbagavalli Weir

Saikiran Y
November 22, 2026

The Supreme Court has dismissed a petition seeking directions to the governments of Tamil Nadu and Keralam to jointly formulate a mechanism for restoring the centuries-old Shenbagavalli weir and its connected Kanyamadugu irrigation channel, leaving a decades-long dispute over the revival of the water-diversion system unresolved. The petition also sought a direction to Tamil Nadu to approach the Centre for referring the dispute to an inter-state water tribunal if the two states failed to reach an agreement.

A bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana dismissed the plea after hearing arguments on Friday. "No case to entertain this writ petition is made out," the bench observed. During the hearing, Justice Bagchi indicated that the court could not compel a state government to initiate litigation.

The petitioner, Ananthan Ayyasamy, approached the court under Article 32 of the Constitution, seeking directions to both states to restore the weir and repair the Kanyamadugu channel up to the Tamil Nadu border. Senior Advocate Srinath Sridevan sought a direction requiring Tamil Nadu to invoke Section 3 of the Inter-State River Water Disputes Act, 1956, for referring the matter to a tribunal.

Located at the confluence of Puliampattithodu and Chokkampattithodu streams in the core area of the Periyar Tiger Reserve in Kerala's Idukki district, the weir dates back to 1773. It was constructed to divert water through the Kanyamadugu channel towards the Kulasekaraperi and Rasingaperi irrigation tanks in Tamil Nadu's Sivagiri taluk. State irrigation records identify its command area as approximately 10,924 acres, while the petitioner has cited a wider network benefiting more than 30,000 acres and around 40 irrigation tanks.

Restoration efforts have remained unsuccessful despite decades of interventions. Tamil Nadu spent Rs 3.25 lakh on repairs between 1959 and 1962 and deposited another Rs 5.15 lakh with Kerala in 1986. However, Kerala returned the amount in 2005, citing Forest Department objections to undertaking work inside the tiger reserve.

The Madras High Court directed Kerala to reconsider the issue in 2006, but the state reiterated its position. Tamil Nadu subsequently sought Centre's intervention in August 2011, offering to reimburse restoration expenses. The latest dismissal leaves bilateral negotiations, possible tribunal proceedings and necessary environmental clearances as potential avenues for resolving the longstanding dispute.

SC Dismisses Plea Seeking Restoration Of 250-Year-Old Shenbagavalli Weir - The Morning Voice