Let's talk: editor@tmv.in
Justice C S Karnan Dies: A Controversial Career Marked By Defiance And Judicial Clashes

Justice C S Karnan Dies: A Controversial Career Marked By Defiance And Judicial Clashes

Saikiran Y
November 15, 2026

Former Madras and Calcutta High Court judge Justice C S Karnan, who became the first sitting High Court judge in India's judicial history to be sentenced to imprisonment for contempt of court, died in Chennai on November 13, 2026, at the age of 71. His death has brought renewed attention to one of the most extraordinary and controversial episodes in the country's judicial history, marked by allegations of caste discrimination, accusations of corruption, confrontations with fellow judges and an unprecedented clash with the Supreme Court.

Born as Karunanidhi in 1955 in Karnatham village of Tamil Nadu's Cuddalore district, Karnan graduated from Madras Law College in 1983 and began practising as an advocate in 1984, primarily handling civil and constitutional matters. He was appointed an additional judge of the Madras High Court in March 2009 and subsequently became a permanent judge. In March 2016, he was transferred to the Calcutta High Court.

His judicial career attracted attention after he repeatedly alleged caste discrimination and corruption within the judiciary, accusing fellow judges and the collegium of unfair practices. In 2011, he approached the National Commission for Scheduled Castes, alleging discrimination because of his Dalit background. His disagreements with the Madras High Court administration and public interventions in judicial appointments further intensified tensions.

The confrontation reached its peak in 2017 when the Supreme Court initiated suo motu contempt proceedings against him following allegations of corruption levelled against several serving and retired judges. A seven-judge Constitution Bench headed by then Chief Justice J S Khehar restricted him from performing judicial and administrative duties.

In an unprecedented move, Karnan issued purported judicial orders against the Supreme Court judges handling his case, accusing them of offences under the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act and sentencing eight judges, including the Chief Justice, to five years of rigorous imprisonment.

On May 9, 2017, the Supreme Court found him guilty of criminal contempt and sentenced him to six months in prison. He evaded arrest for over a month before being apprehended by West Bengal Police in Coimbatore on June 20, shortly after retiring from judicial service on June 12. He was released in December 2017 after completing his sentence.

Controversies continued after retirement. In December 2020, Chennai Police arrested him following the circulation of videos containing derogatory remarks and threats against judges and their female family members. The Madras High Court subsequently granted him bail, considering his medical condition and unconditional apology. He also launched the Anti Corruption Dynamic Party in 2018.

Karnan's legacy remains deeply contested, raising questions about judicial accountability, caste discrimination, institutional independence and judicial discipline. While his allegations highlighted concerns about equality within the judiciary, his confrontation with the Supreme Court became an unprecedented chapter in India's legal history.

Justice C S Karnan Dies: A Controversial Career Marked By Defiance And Judicial Clashes - The Morning Voice